Between Myth and Belief

What happens when a community’s justice system fails, and the line between vigilante law and supernatural lore begins to blur?
In this episode of Between Myth and Belief (formerly Folkloric), Michelle and Beth travel to the dark hollows of Booger Hole, West Virginia. Known for a string of mysterious disappearances and a history of post-Civil War violence, Booger Hole became the stage for one of Appalachia’s most haunting legends: The Witch of Booger Hole.
We dive deep into the tragic story of Lacey Ann Boggs, a woman labeled a witch and targeted by the notorious Clay County Mob. Was she truly "hag-riding" her neighbors through sleep paralysis, or was she a convenient scapegoat for a community gripped by fear and lawlessness?
Whether you’re here for the West Virginia folklore, the Appalachian history, or the true crime mysteries of the 19th century, grab a hot drink and join us in the gray area between what we know and what we believe.
As mentioned in the podcast, here is the Upcoming Events for 4/16 to 5/1 of 2026:
Folklore & Myth Events: April 19 – May 1
April 19: The Cerealia & The Ritual of the Burning Foxes
This was the primary festival for Ceres, the Roman goddess of agriculture. The most evocative (and slightly "feral") ritual involved tying blazing torches to the tails of live foxes and releasing them into the Circus Maximus.
The Lore: It was said to cleanse crops and protect them from vermin, or to represent Ceres' frantic search for her daughter Proserpina with torches in hand.
Links: History of Cerealia | Ceres and the Foxes
April 21: Parilia (Rome’s Birthday)
A pastoral festival dedicated to Pales, the deity of shepherds. This is a day of purification and "city-building" mythology.
The Lore: Shepherds would jump through bonfires of straw and laurel to purify themselves and their flocks. Legend says Romulus founded Rome on this day in 753 BC by plowing a sacred boundary line.
Links: Parilia Traditions | Rome’s Founding Myths
April 23: St. George’s Day
A cornerstone of European dragon lore.
The Lore: The Golden Legend tells of a dragon in Libya that demanded human sacrifices. St. George subdued the beast, and in some versions, the princess led the dragon back to the city on a leash like a "meek beast."
Links: St. George and the Dragon
April 25: St. Mark’s Eve (The Death Vigil)
In British folklore, this was a night of eerie divinations, often focused on mortality and marriage.
The Lore: It was believed that if you sat in the church porch and fasted from 11:00 PM to 1:00 AM, you would see the ghosts of all those in the parish who were destined to die in the coming year entering the church.
Links: St. Mark's Eve Superstitions
April 25: Robigalia (The Red Dog Sacrifice)
A Roman ritual to ward off Robigo, the spirit of grain rust (mildew).
The Lore: To protect the wheat, a priest would sacrifice a red-haired dog. It’s a fascinating look at how ancient cultures personified agricultural diseases as vengeful spirits.
Links: Robigalia Lore
April 30: Walpurgis Night (Hexennacht)
Known as the "Other Halloween," this is the night witches were said to gather on the Brocken, the highest peak in Germany's Harz Mountains.
The Lore: Traditions involve lighting massive bonfires to ward off evil and playing pranks. Offerings of bread with butter and honey (ankenschnitt) were often left out for "phantom hounds."
Links: Walpurgis Night History | Witch Lore in the Harz
May 1: Beltane (The Gaelic Fire Festival)
One of the four major Gaelic seasonal festivals, marking the beginning of summer.
The Lore: This is a "liminal" time when the veil between worlds is thin. Cattle were driven between twin fires for protection, and offerings were left for the Aos Sí (The Fae). It’s also the day of the Maypole, symbolizing fertility and the union of earth and sun.
Links: Beltane Myths & Customs | Fae Offerings & Traditions
Cryptid Anniversaries
April 21–22: The Dover Demon (1977)
One of the most famous short-lived cryptid "flaps" in American history occurred in Dover, Massachusetts.
The Event: Over 24 hours, three teenagers independently reported a creature with glowing orange eyes and a watermelon-shaped head. It was described as having long, spindly fingers and peach-colored, "sandpaper-like" skin.
Links: Dover Demon Records
April 22: The "Strange Animal" of West Sutton (1921)
A more obscure historical sighting from the Pine Barrens region.
The Event: Residents reported a creature that "would answer a horn" with a cry like a wolf, but could also roar like a lion. It was noted for its incredible fleetness and tracks much larger than a wolf's.
Links: Pine Barrens Cryptid Archive
 

In the spring of 1973, in a small Southern Illinois town of about 800 people, something scratched at Henry McDaniel's door. He opened it. What he described was four feet tall, three-legged, pinkish-grey skin, eyes catching the porch light. It sent him rushing for his gun and sent the rest of Enfield into chaos.
Michelle and Beth dig into the 1973 Illinois cryptid sightings from the ground up, the place, the time, the people, and what Southern Illinois in economic decline might have to do with what showed up on Canal Street. They also drag in a French explorer, the Illini legend of the Piasa, the case for an escaped wallaby, and the question of what happens when a town's dread gets heavy enough to need a shape.
 
Whazat.mp3 by macindoe1 -- https://freesound.org/s/52890/ -- License: Sampling+
evening woods Drunen NL 02 151009_0803.wav by klankbeeld -- https://freesound.org/s/333217/ -- License: Attribution 4.0

They were here before us. They will be here after we're gone. And in the meantime, they are definitely watching. For as long as people have been brave enough to go into the woods, trees have given us shelter, oxygen, fruit, and stories. People from all over the world and throughout history have looked up into those branches and felt something old looking back at them.
So the question isn't if trees have power. Should we be afraid of it or respect it?
Join Michelle and Beth as they dig deep into tree folklore, forest mythology, and the very human need to figure out why something that old and that shouldn't make you feel that way makes you feel that way.

Let's breathe in the strange and suffocating tale of the Mad Gasser of Mattoon, the phantom prowler who paralyzed an entire Illinois town in the summer of 1944 with nothing but a sweet smell and a whole lot of wartime dread. We dig into the moments that lit the fuse, the armed vigilantes who followed, and why the army chemical experts found absolutely nothing. Plus, we trace the long, weird history of fear going airborne, from the Glass Harmonica's alleged nerve-shredding powers to Spring-heeled Jack, War of the Worlds, and the surprisingly ancient art of a town losing its collective mind.

Let’s take a walk through a blood soaked history of Greyfriars Kirkyard and the apparitions who do or maybe do not haunt there. We discuss the plague victims, mass graves, the Covenanters, and the monster who may be lurking in the dark. Plus, a bonus illness-induced, emotional rant about humanity and how we treat one another. 
 
 
 
 
R4_00597_EXP01_Horror_atmosphere by kevp888 -- https://freesound.org/s/759670/ -- License: Attribution 4.0

Follow along with us as we enter a different realm, beyond the known and into... Toronto, Canada. Where we watch the 1970s every day citizens embark upon a journey of mysticism and science. Philip never existed but he has gained a life in the minds of those who created him and for those of us who uncover this, for all intents and purposes, successful attempt to create a ghost. 
 
View the documentary The Philip Experiment

Most of us love to dance. School dances, dance clubs, weddings, etc., are all opportunities for those of us with the passion but not the professional skill to shake our groove thing. We dance until we need a drink or they switch to a song we dislike. But what if you couldn’t stop? What if your friends and neighbors were all dancing with you? What if none of you could stop? Join us as we explore the mysterious phenomenon known as the Dancing Plagues.

Time is like a river, or perhaps a babbling brook. Michelle and Beth jump into the time stream and visit fantastical places like across the street or down the road. Every place has a time slip story, those moments that capture you like a leaf in a dust devil and keep you twirling until you find yourself no longer in Kansas but out of time.

The mystery, the history, and the…science? This week Beth and Michelle discuss an area of the U.S. they both love as they set the scene for many myths and lore to come. This area can make a person ask a lot of questions and give few answers in return but will definitely leave a ton of room for speculation. So, close the curtains, don’t whistle, and ignore the voice in the woods calling your name. Don’t worry, it’s just the Appalachian Mountains.

Some beings endure over the centuries, not just surviving the encroachment of the modern world but thriving within new mediums. Whether it is in a Marvel movie, video games or a podcast about folklore, some beings still retain their relevance. Michelle and Beth discuss the nature and duality of Baba Yaga and her walking hut. 
 
Beyond the Mother Metaphor: Baba Yaga's Ecofeminist Manifesto
 
Music by Ønetent from Pixabay