Between Myth and Belief
Michelle is a witch attuned to the supernatural. Beth is a skeptical secular witch. Together they explore folklore, cryptids, ghost stories, and legends from the Appalachian Mountains and beyond.
Weaving faith and doubt, wonder and wit into stories that echo with mystery, they live in the space between the magical and the mundane, offering their listeners both chills and charm.
Michelle is a witch attuned to the supernatural. Beth is a skeptical secular witch. Together they explore folklore, cryptids, ghost stories, and legends from the Appalachian Mountains and beyond.
Weaving faith and doubt, wonder and wit into stories that echo with mystery, they live in the space between the magical and the mundane, offering their listeners both chills and charm.
Episodes

Dec 7, 2025
The Mothman
Dec 7, 2025
Dec 7, 2025
1 hr 15 min
Michelle's favorite cryptid finally swoops into an episode! Beth takes a skeptical, if empathetic, eye to the cryptids origins. Everything you ever wanted to know -or hypothesize- about the Mothman is in this episode. Is the Mothman real or a mass hallucination? A harbinger or a watcher? Or maybe a lonely soul looking for a companion. The Mothman may be the only one who knows.
"The Mothman Song" by Melissa Starfall
Dec 7, 2025
1 hr 15 min

Nov 23, 2025
The Cailleach
Nov 23, 2025
Nov 23, 2025
52 min
The Cailleach, ancient hag, goddess of winter, she is the shaper of mountains. She is the keeper of storms and the weaver of endings. In this episode we discuss her steps through Celtic myth from Ireland to Scotland and beyond. We will uncover tales of icy reign, the power to sculpt land and her dual nature which is in the end so very human.
Music track: Heritage by Pufino
Source: https://freetouse.com/music
Copyright Free Music (Free Download)
Nov 23, 2025
52 min

Nov 9, 2025
Martyrdom
Nov 9, 2025
Nov 9, 2025
1 hr 26 min
What started as a morbid fascination with how some saints met their deaths, this episode turned an emotional corner as we discuss different martyrs and how they came to be. Michelle focuses on the ancient past and the more ‘creative’ endings these saints met. Beth touches on more recent history and we find ourselves angered and appalled. Why does someone need to die just to further their message? Could change have come about if these individuals were allowed to live? What gives someone the right to claim another human’s life? What sicko decided to name the flayed saint the patron of tanners? Come listen and be frustrated by the lack of answers to these questions.
Martin Luther King Jr - I Have A Dream
Harvey Milk - The Hope Speech
Nov 9, 2025
1 hr 26 min

Oct 19, 2025
The Headless Horseman
Oct 19, 2025
Oct 19, 2025
1 hr 42 sec
Fog hangs heavy, the road ahead is barely visible by the light of your lantern. You hear the thudding beat of hooves in the distance, perhaps a messenger on his task. An angry orange light ahead pierces the fog, and the heavy lantern drops away from your numb fingers as you stare in shock at the headless figure wrapped in a dark cloak astride a black steed. It's upheld hand gripping a jack-o'-lantern, it's blazing orange eyes fall upon you and you feel the light burrow into your soul. The last thing you hear is your name escaping the horseman as if being pulled from a wet grave. Michelle and Beth take you on a journey across the Atlantic and back for this figure from folklore and myth.
Oct 19, 2025
1 hr 42 sec

Oct 5, 2025
Clinton Road
Oct 5, 2025
Oct 5, 2025
1 hr 19 min
Every state and every town has that one road where we are all a bit more cautious. Some of them are dangerous and have taken many lives, others have stores of phantom hitchhikers or ghostly headlights. Throw in a castle and a cryptid and you have one of the scariest stretches of asphalt: Clinton Road.
Oct 5, 2025
1 hr 19 min

Sep 21, 2025
The Tooth Fairy
Sep 21, 2025
Sep 21, 2025
54 min
What are your teeth worth? It might be bartered for protection, traded for good health, or you may find a shiny half dollar as payment. We discuss the mythical creature known as the Tooth Fairy and it's many international incarnations.
Sep 21, 2025
54 min

Sep 7, 2025

Aug 23, 2025
Welcome to Between Myth and Belief
Aug 23, 2025
Aug 23, 2025
46 sec
Between Myth and Belief is a bi-weekly podcast that will take a look at all the things in this world that make humans feel insignificant and scared or uncomfortable and confused. We will talk about the lore, the magic, the history, and the cryptids, as we discuss their significance in culture and society, both past and present. So tune in every other Sunday with Beth and Michelle.
Aug 23, 2025
46 sec









